The effectiveness of Solanum panduriforme (Mey) based extracts on the cabbage aphid, Brevicoryne brassicae (Linnacus) on brassicas

Abstract

Brassicas are important vegetable crops grown for home consumption and market gardening in eastern and southern Africa. However, productivity is affected by aphids, through both direct feeding and disease transmission. Botanical insecticides have potential to control the aphids, but so far few plants have been evaluated for use on brassicas. This study was conducted to evaluate the effectiveness of Solanum panduriforme to control aphids on brassicas. Botanical extracts from three parts of S. panduriforme were assessed for their insecticidal effects on the cabbage aphid, Brevicoryne brassicae. The extracts from leaf powder (LP), ripe berry powder (BP), fresh ripe berries (RB) and fresh unripe berries (UB) were extracted with four solvents; water, ethanol, hexane and diethyl ether, using homogenisation, maceration and solvent-assisted / sequential extraction methods. The effectiveness of the extracts was determined by laboratory bioassays as well as by plant assays in the screen house and under field conditions. The experiments were replicated three or four times depending on the assays and the design used was completely randomized design (CRD). The immature (LP and UB) plant parts were generally more effective than the mature (BP and RB) plant parts, with mortalities ranging from 100 % down to 40 % respectively depending on assays. Ethanol extracts were more effective than aqueous extracts (LP 96% and 63%; BP 96% and 64%; RB 100% and 64%; UB 100% and 90%). The dried crude extracts from hexane were more effective than di-ethyl ether extracts. The group chemical analysis indicated presence of alkaloids in the berries (BP, RB and UB), which were absent in the leaves (LP). Phenolic compounds and flavonoids were present in all the extracts (LP, BP, RB, and UB). Saponins were present in the fresh parts (RB and UB). The results show how the locally available S. panduriforme plants can be used as an aphicide to control aphids on brassicas. Farmers can directly prepare an easy and cheap botanical