Assessment of the use of ceramic water filters with silver nitrate as point-of-use water treatment devices in Dertig, North West Province, South Africa

Abstract

Water borne diseases due to inadequate and unsafe drinking water is a global challenge that has led to a significant number of deaths and illnesses reported annually. These diseases are prevalent in less-developed countries, especially in rural areas where there is shortage of basic infrastructure and inadequate funds for piped water systems in individual households. Community members are forced to resort to collecting water from communal water points and later storing the water in containers for daily use. Recontamination of microbiologically safe drinking water during and after collection from the water source has been recognised as a problem; hence treating water at household level is one way to provide potable water for affected communities. The microbiological quality of household water may be improved by using point-of-use treatment technologies such as chemical disinfection, solar disinfection and ceramic water filters. Some of these technologies are expensive, less effective and difficult to implement in rural communities. This research thus focused on ceramic water filters and finding an appropriate method for silver application so as to produce filters that are effective in both the provision of clean drinking water and the release of silver levels that are safe for human consumption. An assessment of the efficiency of ceramic water filters made with silver nitrate as point-of -use water treatment device in Dertig Village, North West Province, South Africa was carried out. During production of filters made with silver nitrate, the filters undergo firing in an electric kiln and ionic silver is reduced to metallic nanopatches dispersed throughout the porous ceramic media. Both filters made with silver nitrate and conventional silver nanoparticles impregnated ceramic water filters were manufactured at the PureMadi Dertig Ceramic Filter Facility, South Africa. Resulting filters were evaluated and quantified for total coliform and E. coli removal as well as silver concentration in the effluent. Ceramic water filters made with silver nitrate had a high removal efficiency for total coliforms (94.7%) and E. coli (99.3%). A comparison of the performance of filters made with silver nitrate and silver nanoparticles in the provision of potable water was carried out and results showed that the different filters had similar levels of total coliform and E. coli removal, although the silver nitrate filters produced the highest average removal of 97.23% while silver nanoparticles filters produced the lowest average removal of 85.43%. Reasonable silver levels were obtained in effluent from all filters. Average effluent silver levels were 0.07±0.04mg/L, 0.6±1.10 mg/L and 0.8±1.0mg/L for 1 g, 2 g and silver nanoparticle filters, respectively (below the EPA and WHO standard of 100 mg/L). Because silver nitrate filters resulted in the lowest effluent silver concentrations, this could potentially increase the effective life span of the filter. A cost analysis of the process proved that it was cheaper to produce ceramic water filters using silver nitrate as the chemical can be purchased locally and also eliminates labour related costs. Thus, filters made using silver nitrate could potentially improve performance, reduce production costs, and increase safety of production for workers. The results obtained from this study will be applied to improve the ceramic filtration technology as point-of-use water treatment device in an effort to reduce health problems associated with microbial contamination of water stored at household level.